Skeptic Tank Text Archive File

By: David Rice
To: Arthur Biele

AB> Dr. Al Carlisle of the Utah State Prison System has
AB> estimated that between forty and sixty thousand
AB> satanic[sic] ritualistic murders occur in the US
AB> each year.

Which is, of course, a lie based upon your occult agenda.
"Doctor" Carlisle ASSUMED murders were taking place (despite the
total and complete LACK of evidence that these murders WERE EVEN
TAKING PLACE) and then claimed Satanists were responsible for
them (again with no evidence for such a bizarre claim, other than
his cult's agenda).

Paraphrase from Ms. Moonstone:
   "Dr." Al Carlisle of the Utah State Penitentiary System in
   1985: Carlisle questioned inmates about involvement in
   "human sacrifice 'cults.'" The figures he arrived at were
   50,000 to 60,000 human sacrifices a year. He arrived at
   this figure by taking the number of alleged "cults" and
   multiplying it by the number of alleged sacrifices per
   year per "cult" and arrived at his baseless conclusion.
   When asked where the bodies were, he says they are
   disposed of in many ways, including:

   1. Eaten and the bones used for ritual implements. (Why
   has there -NEVER- been any of these bones produced? Why
   has there -NEVER- been an ex-member come forward with
   evidence?)

   2. Fed to animals such as hogs or dogs. (Hogs and dogs
   don't consume bones: see above.)

   3. Buried (Despite numerous claims by both children and
   adult "survivors", and much digging, no bodies have yet
   been found. Authur's lies would have us believe that twice
   the number of Americans killed in Viet Nam are being
   killed and burried EACH YEAR without a single soul
   breathing a word of it.)

   4. Dumped at sea. (Certainly believable for those who live
   near an ocean. However, one clipping in the CWR files has
   a kid in El Paso Texas saying he witnessed a murder and
   the body was taken out to sea and dumped. It's a LONG way
   from El Paso to the ocean.)

   5. Dumped down abandoned mine shafts. (Certainly a
   possibility. But 60,000 a year?!?!?!?)

   6. Burned and the ashes saved. (The old myth of the
   "portable crematorium.)

The FBI reports slightly less than 20,000 murders per year,
throughout the nation, of which 85% are immediately solved with
the murderer(s) caught at or near the sean. For the large bulk of
the remainder, the murder(s) are known and are letter apprehended.
Out of the 20,000 or so muders each year, only a few hundred are
left unsolved.

So, as we can see, Authur has =LIED= to us again. Why am I not
surprised?